I think the Rouge Reward provides the best ROI. Not certain on current stock, but IIRC its exactly 2500 points for $100. That beats the $10 per 500 ratio easily.

> My logic was to wait and try to snag the $100 Rouge Reward, but they sell out instantly and Im stressed Ill miss it. The Rouge Reward is the only way to go if you want to be satisfied with your point value. Everything else is basically a waste. I grabbed one recently and it worked well to cover a big chunk of my bill. Since you have over 2500 points, just be ready on the app exactly when they drop on Tuesday or Thursday mornings. If you're trying to make that $150 stretch, I'd suggest looking at PriceDropCatch to see if any of your items are about to hit a better price point. I've had no complaints using it for my hauls lately. For the actual products, just stick with Sephora Collection stuff. You can't go wrong with that brand and the quality is usually solid for way less cash. Don't bother with the bazaar sets... they're never worth the points.