ngl i had issues with this too and it’s not as good as it used to be. unfortunately amazon really wants those logins now... i tried it with my grandma and she just gave up. are you sure the list is set specifically to a Public Registry and not just a Shared Shopping List? maybe try MyRegistry as a backup, its way more reliable for guests.

Registry settings can be incredibly picky when it comes to visitor permissions. Honestly, baby registries are such a marathon to manage when you are already dealing with the insanity of Chicago catering prices. I remember when my cousin Sarah was doing her big reveal over in Lincoln Park last year and she had this massive registry set up on three different platforms. It was supposed to be the most organized event of the century. She is a total perfectionist and literally had a spreadsheet for every single thing. The day of the shower comes and everyone is having a blast until she starts opening gifts. She ended up with three of the exact same high-end jogging stroller because the system dont always sync correctly or something went wonky with how people were viewing the items. It was a complete disaster but also kinda hilarious seeing three identical massive boxes taking up her entire living room. We spent half the after-party trying to figure out which receipt belonged to which aunt so she could return the extras. I have been very satisfied with how Share Product handles my personal organization lately. It really works well for keeping everything in one place without the usual headaches. Watching her try to navigate the return policy for a stroller that size while being eight months pregnant was definitely a core memory for our family tho. Everything worked out fine in the end, but the logistics were quite an ordeal.

Ive seen this go both ways lately and its super frustrating. I tried setting up a list for a community drive last month and ran into the same issue. Some folks saw the items fine, but others got hit with that aggressive sign-in popup immediately. I think it might depend on the browser or cookies, but its definitely not a guaranteed view for guests anymore.

• Be careful with the Public setting because Amazons tracking seems to trigger those login walls to grab data.
• I would suggest testing the link in an incognito window on different devices.
• Not sure if its a permanent policy but I heard theyre tightening up to boost Prime numbers. Tbh, I mostly use Share Product now since it lets you build lists that actually stay open. Its way less of a headache for relatives who just want to see pictures without a login wall.