In my experience, you should definitely grab two separate high-quality docks instead of a combo unit. I tried a generic 2-in-1 dock last year and it was honestly such a disaster... the controllers would barely stay on the pins and the charging was suuuuper slow. It was basically a total waste of money imo. Here is the technical breakdown of what actually works:

• Sony PlayStation 5 DualSense Charging Station: The official one uses the bottom click-in ports which is way sturdier than using the top USB-C port.
• PowerA DualShock 4 Charging Station for PlayStation 4: I prefer this over the official Sony PS4 dock cuz of the spring-loaded mechanism. You literally just press down to lock it in.
• Razer Quick Charging Stand for PS5: These look amazing but they only charge one controller at a time, so they arent great if youre trying to save space. So yeah, stick to official Sony or PowerA stuff for the best build quality. peace!

Sooo basically I went through this exact same thing about six months ago. My desk looked like a literal snakes nest with all those micro-usb and usb-c cables everywhere... it was honestly driving me crazy lol. I started looking for a combo dock that could handle both my DS4 and DualSense at once, but to be honest, I got kinda worried about the safety side of things. Some of those generic all-in-one stations you see on random sites look super sketchy and I didnt want to risk frying my expensive controller batteries just to save a few bucks. It just felt too risky for me. I would suggest just getting two separate docks from a brand you can actually trust. If you wanna stay budget-friendly but still have that sturdy build, the PowerA Twin Charging Station for DualSense Wireless Controllers is usually around $25 and it works great. It has that click-down design so the controllers dont just slide off when you bump the desk. For the older console, I used the PowerA Charging Station for PlayStation 4 which you can usually find for like $18 or $20 these days if you look around. I actually tried a super cheap third-party brand first, but the build quality was trash and the controllers would barely stay connected... plus the base got weirdly hot which is a huge red flag. So yeah, my lesson learned was basically that it is better to spend the extra ten bucks for something like the official Sony PlayStation 5 DualSense Charging Station which is about $30 now. It keeps everything organized and you wont have to worry about electrical issues. Anyway... hope that helps!

TIL! Thanks for sharing

Commenting to find later

So basically the consensus is that trying to find one single dock to rule them all usually ends in a total disaster lol. Like the other guys mentioned, those generic combo units are honestly a total waste of money cuz they're flimsy and charge at a snails pace. I have been gaming for like 15 years and learned the hard way that cutting corners on power stuff just leads to headaches and potentially fried batteries... definitely not worth it!! If you wanna keep things tidy without breaking the bank, sticking to two separate high-quality ones is highkey the move. From a value perspective, you dont always need to buy the official Sony brand to get a sturdy build. I actually recommend the OIVO PS5 Controller Charging Station for your DualSense. It is sooo much cheaper than the official one but still has a really solid click-down design so the controllers dont just slide off. For the PS4 Pro side of things, check out the Fosmon Dual Micro-USB Charging Station for PS4. It has been around forever and is super reliable for the price. Plus, it uses the bottom EXT port rather than the fragile micro-usb on top, which is a life saver for long-term durability. Going with two dedicated stations actually helps organize the desk better anyway cuz you can tuck the older PS4 one further back and keep the PS5 one front and center. It seriously saves you from that cable nightmare!! gl!

Great info, saved!